In the first installment in the Evermore series, teenage Ever discovers her psychic powers and meets the mysterious Damen. Now in this sequel, she has become more confident with her unique abilities, but just as she begins to feel more at ease fate forces an impossible decision upon her: Damen falls fatally ill and needs her help, but if she saves him, she will sacrifice the opportunity to correct the past and save her family who died in a tragic car accident.

Eager to learn everything she can about her new abilities as an Immortal, Ever turns to her beloved Damen to show her the way, but just as her powers are increasing, his are in decline, and as she searches for a way to save him, she finds herself with a wrenching choice to make.