Review 1:
"...[A] masterpiece..." -- Rating: A
Source: Entertainment Weekly
p.100 08/20/1999
Review 2:
"...It's a meditation on the collapse of the old order of European civilization....There is a quiet voluptuousness; the camera doesn't point or intrude, but glides..."
Source: Chicago Sun-Times
p.5 10/03/1999
Review 3:
"In '38: a New York Film Critics best-direction citation to Jean Renoir and a best-picture Oscar nomination."
Source: USA Today
p.6D 02/15/2005
Review 4:
"...One of the greatest films ever made....The performances -- from Gabin, Pierre Frensay, Erich von Stroheim and Marcel Dalio -- are as fresh as they were in 1937..."
Source: Los Angeles Times
p.C47 12/16/1999
Review 5:
"[An] anti-war classic....As in so much of Renoir's work, it's the humanism that resonates most strongly."
Source: Sight and Sound
p.89 01/01/2007